Which US airline has the best premium economy product?
Recently, Simple Flying magazine highlighted the world’s top ten airlines by revenue, with the three largest US airlines, American, Delta and United, taking the top spots. All three airlines are known for their great offering of hard and soft products on long-haul flights. We look at the three airlines’ distinct economy products and identify what stands out.
Seats and comfort
|Premium economy seats||Width (in)||throw)||lean (in)|
|American Airlines||18.5 – 19||38||6|
|Delta Airlines||18.5 – 19||38||7|
|United Airlines||17.1 – 19||35 – 38||7|
American Airlines offers premium economy seating on a variety of its widebody aircraft, including the Boeing 777 (-200 and -300ER) and the 787 (-8 and -9). The airline offers 38 inches of seat pitch on all aircraft. The Premium Economy seat width is 18.5 inches (A330, 777-300ER, 787-8) or 19 inches (777-200, 787-9).
Photo: Vincenzo Pace | Simple flying
Delta Air Lines’ seat offerings are no different when it comes to widebody aircraft. Delta offers a 38-inch pitch and 18.5-inch pitch on its Airbus A330-900 and A350-900 aircraft.
United Airlines has the greatest variety of offerings when it comes to premium economy class seats on its long-haul aircraft. The carrier offers premium economy seats on the Boeing 757-200, 767-300ER, 777(-200, -300ER) and 787(-8, -9, and -10). United Airlines has five different seat designs for its premium economy seats, ranging from 17.1 inches wide and 35 inches wide (Boeing 777-200) to 19 inches wide and 38 inches wide on all Boeing 787 models.
Photo: United Airlines
It is worth noting that seat space and width are similar in all airlines. However, Delta and United offer a 7-inch recline, while premium economy seats on American Airlines only recline 6 inches.
Services and prices on board
All three airlines offer large in-flight entertainment screens, headphones, and amenity kits. While the pillow and blanket brands of the three airlines differ, the products are comparable in quality and comfort. All airlines offer free alcoholic and soft drinks, meals served in crockery, priority boarding, and a generous baggage allowance.
|American Airlines||JFK – LHR||$1,256|
|Delta Airlines||JFK – LHR||$1,266|
|United Airlines||EWR – LHR||$3,652|
Looking at ticket information between New York (JFK) and London Heathrow (LHR) on June 1, 2024, American Airlines is offering a one-way premium economy fare of $1,256. Aside from wider seating and upscale cabin services, the fare includes two free checked bags, priority security (at participating locations), and priority boarding.
Delta Air Lines offers a one-way premium economy fare of $1,266 on the same route. Delta advertises that this travel class comes with a wider seat, a deeper recline, and an extendable legrest. Premium Select also features attentive service by the hostess and includes a complimentary amenity kit. The fare provides priority check-in, security, boarding and baggage handling. The airline also offers two free checked bags.
Photo: Vincenzo Pace I am a simple flyer
United Airlines offers a flight between New York (EWR) and LHR, and a one-way ticket costs $3,651, nearly three times the price of American and Delta. Although the service is not from JFK International Airport, the distance and travel class are similar. The airline offers premium seating, priority check-in and boarding, and two pieces of free baggage. Given the comfort, amenities, aircraft type, and amenities, our choice is Delta Air Lines.
What are your thoughts on how premium economy compares between the big three US airlines? Have you traveled with one or more of them in premium economy class? Share your experience in the comments section.